When it comes to the Fallout series, there are two leading contenders for people’s favorite game: Fallout 3 and New Vegas. Both games have their own unique pros and cons, but which one is the ultimate winner?
Some people might immediately say that Fallout 3 is better because of its more open-world environment, while others might prefer New Vegas for its more in-depth storyline. So, which game is really the best?
In this article, we will compare and contrast Fallout 3 and New Vegas to see which one comes out on top.
So without any further ado, let’s get started.
Main Differences Between Fallout 3 vs New Vegas:
+ New Vegas’s story is more compelling than Fallout 3’s. New Vegas makes players feel like they are really experiencing all sides of the story, whether it be helping the struggling townsfolk or destroying them for money.
— Fallout 3 has a very “list-y” approach to quests; players are basically given a series of tasks to complete. I understand that Bethesda was trying to make this game as streamlined as possible, but the point I, if you don’t like reading all the time, then this game might not be for you.
New Vegas has a more in-depth approach to quests; players have some choice on how they want to finish them. Players can choose to ally themselves with different factions and get a different outcome of the overall story.
— In Fallout 3, you don’t really get attached to your companions because most of them either die or leave you. This is one of Fallout 3’s main flaws – your companions are essentially disposable.
In New Vegas, the companion system has been revamped so that players actually care about their companions. Companions in New Vegas can be injured, killed, and even romanced. This makes the game a lot more personal, and players feel like they have more of a stake in the game.
— The Graphics in Fallout 3 are dated, plain and simple. This is especially noticeable when you compare them to New Vegas.
The Graphics in New Vegas is much better, even if they are not as good as some of the newer games out there. However, the Graphics are still good enough that players will not be disappointed.
— In Fallout 3, you are able to fast travel to different locations whenever you want. This is an excellent feature for people who don’t want to walk everywhere.
In New Vegas, fast traveling is not an option. Players have to travel on foot everywhere. This may be annoying for some players who are not willing to take the time to truly explore the world of New Vegas.
— Fallout 3 has a much more extensive crafting system, allowing you to build your own weapons and even create your own electricity with water and steam generators. Crafting is one of Fallout 3’s strong suits.
In New Vegas, the crafting system is not as extensive as Fallout 3’s. Players can only craft weapons and armor, and there are not as many options for players to choose from.
— In Fallout 3, you can pause the game and access your Pip-Boy at any time.
In New Vegas, you cannot pause the game. This is a major drawback considering that some of Fallout 3’s quests consist of long periods of inactivity while players are unable to access their Pip-Boy.
Fallout 3 has an extensive level system with perks for different skills and attributes, allowing players to create unique characters with various special abilities.
New Vegas has a level cap of 30, but the level system is not as unique as Fallout 3’s. Without the extensive perks, players will essentially be playing the same character over and over again.
Fallout 3 vs New Vegas – The Main Comparison
One of the biggest differences between Fallout 3 and New Vegas is the world that each game takes place.
Fallout 3’s world is much more open than New Vegas, allowing for more exploration and giving players the ability to do whatever they want whenever they want. However, this also means fewer quests are available in Fallout 3 locations instead of focusing on delivering the main storyline.
On the other hand, New Vegas has locations that are much more compressed together than Fallout 3’s, so not as much exploring is possible. However, New Vegas compensates for this by having many different side quests to do in each location.
So, the winner here is clearly New Vegas. While Fallout 3 does have an open-world environment, New Vegas does just as good a job and even better for having so many side quests to do.
New Vegas wins in this area, too. While Fallout 3 has an excellent main storyline, it gets quite uninteresting after the first few missions because of how straightforward it is.
However, the New Vegas storyline has many more twists and turns that keep players hooked until the end.
Additionally, Fallout 3’s ending can be pretty unsatisfying for some players, while New Vegas’s ending is much more satisfying.
Ultimately, New Vegas is the better game of the two. It has a more exciting plot, a better world to explore, and a more satisfying ending. Fallout 3 is still a great game, but New Vegas just beats it out in every category.
While Fallout 3 has some great characters, New Vegas takes the cake with its incredibly well-written cast. From the moment players meet the first character, they’ll be hooked on the dialogue and story.
The only downside to New Vegas’s cast is that there are too many of them. It can be hard to keep track of them all.
Overall, even though Fallout 3 has great characters also, New Vegas wins this one hand down. It can be hard to keep track of all the characters in New Vegas at times, but they are still much better than anything that Fallout 3 has to offer.
Another area where New Vegas beats Fallout 3 is in companions. New Vegas has many different companions that players can pick up and take along with them on their journey through the desert.
Each one of these companions brings something unique to the table and feels like a natural person, unlike so many other video game characters.
On the other hand, Fallout 3 has a much smaller cast of companions, and most of them are quite forgettable. They’re not bad, but they definitely don’t compare to the companions found in New Vegas.
New Vegas easily wins this category. It has many more companions than Fallout 3, each one with its own unique personality that makes them special, and they’re all far better written than the companions of Fallout 3.
Here, New Vegas is the clear winner again. While Fallout 3’s combat can be pretty great at times, it can also be very frustrating – especially when enemies constantly gang up on you and cheap-shot your character. New Vegas remedies this by having much less frustrating combat.
Both games’ combat is still significant today because of how well they’ve stood the test of time. However, New Vegas takes the cake here because of just how annoying the combat is in Fallout 3. It has much more enjoyable and satisfying gunplay than Fallout 3 does.
There are pros and cons to both games when it comes to gameplay. Fallout 3’s shooting mechanics are much better than New Vegas, while New Vegas’s melee combat is much better.
Additionally, Fallout 3 has a more complex perk system than New Vegas, which can make it more difficult for some players to choose their build. On the other hand, New Vegas has a more straightforward perk system that is more easily navigated.
So, Fallout 3 comes out as the winner for having better shooting mechanics, while New Vegas has a more user-friendly perk system.
This brings us to the end of our article about Fallout 3 vs. New Vegas. In summary:
*The World: New Vegas wins this round for having many side quests, while Fallout 3’s open-world environment is mainly there to deliver the main storyline.
*The Plot: New Vegas wins this round thanks to its engaging and unpredictable storyline.
*The Characters: New Vegas has far more interesting and developed characters than Fallout 3.
*The Gameplay: Fallout 3 wins this round for having better shooting mechanics, while New Vegas’ melee combat is much better.
In the end, New Vegas is the clear winner in every category. It has a more interesting plot, a better world to explore, more well-written characters, and much more satisfying combat.
At the end of the day, it’s up to the individual player to decide which game they prefer. Both Fallout 3 and New Vegas are great games in their own right, with their own unique pros and cons.
So, the best thing to do is give them both a try and see which one you like better!
- Skyrim vs Witcher 3: What’s the best one?
- Endless Space 2 vs Stellaris: which one is better?
- Dark Souls vs Skyrim – which one comes out on top?
So, there you have it – the ultimate Fallout 3 vs. New Vegas comparison. Both games are fantastic in their own right, but New Vegas comes out on top in all aspects.
So, In the end, New Vegas is the clear winner in every category. It has a more exciting plot, a better world to explore, more well-written characters, and much more satisfying combat.
Both games are still great today because of how well they’ve stood the test of time. However, New Vegas takes the cake here because of just how annoying the combat is in Fallout 3. It has much more enjoyable and satisfying gunplay than Fallout 3 does.
Let us know what you think is better in the comments section. Feel free to share the post with your gaming friends if you liked it.